On Friday, August 17, 2018 at 4:15:44 PM UTC-4, Peter Lemken wrote:
> number_six <***@hotmail.com> wrote: On Wednesday, September 21, 2016
> > at 6:08:44 PM UTC-7, Bozo wrote: Yuji Takahashi ( born 1938 ) plays
> >> Rzewski's " People United " variations, I believe the 1979 ALM Records lp
> >> recording re-issued on cd in 1989 :
> >> https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0Gm7RgdzeWM
> >> It has been several years since I listened to my Hamelin cd , have little
> >> memory, but Takahashi impresses with a wealth of detail , wonderful
> >> narrative quality and momentum , kept my attention.The next time you're
> >> in the mood for this work , have a listen.
> > Listened to this last night, thanks for posting. I see Oppens has a new
> > version on Cedille. I have the old recording on Vanguard.
> Nothing comes close to Rzewski's own live recording from the 2007 Miami
> piano festival.
> And in terms of studio recordings, Igor Levit is a must - this piano is a
> beauty and so is the recording location.
> Peter Lemken
> Nature abhors crude hacks.
Yes Levit's recording is a must--it's how I discovered this brilliant composition. I have both his recording and Oppens's second version. But Levit's recording, great as it is, doesn't compare with the experience of hearing him play this extraordinary piece live, as I did at Tanglewood two nights ago--the sheer physical demands of this piece, to say nothing of the technical ones, make it like an Olympian athletic feat. Yet after 50 minutes Levit still had plenty of energy in reserve for a longer than usual improvisation at the end, in which along with "avanti popoli" and Brecht/Eisler's "Solidaritätslied" he worked in a brief allusion to Woody Guthrie's "This Land is Your Land." Afterward he told me it simply came to him in the midst of the improvisation.